| ALL-GYBL TEAM 1946 | |||
| First Team | Second Team | ||
| C | Aaron Robinson, GHE (BA.323, OPS.963, HR 16, RBI 102, R 62) | C | Andy Seminick, ATB (BA.287, OPS.779, HR 10, RBI 61, R 58) |
| 1B | Phil Cavarretta, NWC (BA .310, OPS .916, HR 13, RBI 107, R 122) | 1B | Mickey Vernon, DCG (BA .340, OPS .909, HR 9, RBI 101, R 109) |
| 2B | Jerry Priddy, NWC (BA .293, OPS .794, HR 9, RBI 81, R 85) | 2B | Eddie Stanky, GCW (BA .258, OPS .739, HR 4, RBI 44, R 129) |
| 3B | Whitey Kurowski, ACB (BA .301, OPS .870, HR 21, RBI 135, R 122, GW 25) | 3B | Graddy Hatton, GCW (BA .288, OPS .827, HR 12, RBI 89, R 69) |
| SS | Johnny Pesky, PRC (BA .361, OPS .890, HR 4, RBI 54, R 134) | SS | Luke Appling, ACB (BA .325, OPS .837, HR 8, RBI 83, R 111) |
| LF | Ted Williams, GHE (BA .297, OPS 1.132, HR 47, RBI 136, R 158) | LF | Stan Musial, CDC (BA .379, OPS 1.099, HR 21, RBI 111, R 124) |
| CF | Stan Spence, GHE (BA .283, OPS .899, HR 21, RBI 134, R 110, GW 18) | CF | Barney McCosky, ACB (BA .380, OPS .942, HR 4, RBI 78, R 90) |
| RF | Buddy Lewis, NWC (BA .320, OPS .887, HR 11, RBI 120, R 118) | RF | Hank Edwards, PRC (BA .316, OPS .955, HR 10, RBI 104, R 99) |
| SP | Tex Hughson, ACB (28-7, GS 38, ERA 2.18, WHIP 1.06, K 191, CG 20, SH 5 ) | SP | Hal Newhouser, GCW (23-10, GS 36, ERA 2.47, WHIP 1.20, K 249, CG 15, SH 4) |
| RP | Earl Caldwell, PRC (9-2, SV 21, G 71, ERA 3.93, WHIP 1.48, K 33) | RP | Junior Thompson, GCW (5-5, SV 17, G 51, ERA 3.61, WHIP 1.41, K 25) |